In dot com. Welcome to CSN Washington dot com Sebastien south on a Redskins insider -- Halard who joins me now. Let's put a little game of should they stay or should they go it is now time for player valuation is the Redskins have been eliminated from the post season hot. Let's start with the most important position Donovan McNabb should station got. Thank you should stay because if you look at the other options just on this roster John -- Rex Grossman and around -- week. Get through next year at Donovan his contract is manageable but here's the reason I think they stick with McNabb is. They don't know when their offseason conditioning -- is there they won't know when they can get a guy in the start learn the playbook. Let's say to mid August that you have three weeks to get a new guy ready thank you stick with McNabb for another year and so I think you'll come back. Staying in the redskins' backfield Clinton Portis is a guy who for a long time is kind of carry the mantle. For the Redskins running game 648. Yards short of John Reagan's team record will have a chance to break that next year I don't think he will. -- even if he wants to come back is going to be had a really reduced rate I don't know if Clinton wants to take that kind of pay cut. -- still of the mind even know he's had a lot of injuries that he can still be an every down back. Few of the Redskins what proof is there that that can happen but ankle what's gonna happen next two weeks can Ryan Torrain stay healthy. For a long period of time like this and be productive as he's on audition right now. Casey rob back another question mark on the offensive line a guy who's 33 years old I mean you look at this team they've got to get younger and they've got to get better on the offensive line. He's you guys can. You can afford to keep around I think you do just for another year in the case McNabb it's such an important position a fraud in accord with inflicted stagger could be a -- that eventually moves to guard to center but. Fans like to beat up Casey but -- now locker room it's like he's a good field general McNabb -- -- -- so I think if he can get an earlier I don't rob -- of your thoughts. Santana Moss another older player 31 he's got over seventy catches so far this season 71 to be exact is you got -- You can count on any big time play making role I'm not a big time playmaker role anymore but I think he comes back because. Who else does that mean Q do you really wanna go into week one -- anti anti Chinese are -- more receivers he's a complementary guys so. Moscow is back but just by his comments after the game on Sunday. What does he wanna come back I just going to be a couple receivers out there in free agency. -- let's switch over to defense now and let's start at the top of the defense Jim Haslett a guy who was taken a beating this year not just from the DC media but obviously from the fans as well. Is there a chance that we could see him gone after just yet I think there's a chance I think but I think he's -- Michigan State for a -- here because. Mike -- -- to realize it's 43 to 34 transition it doesn't happen overnight. Everybody says Green Bay -- it -- would have slid to first round draft picks that helps the Redskins don't have that kind of firepower in terms of draft picks up. I Catholic it's another year but I there's going to be a lot of personal changes that. We talk about guys get beat up in the media and by the fans maybe there's nobody out there who takes it more than Carlos Rogers probably dropped interceptions fans that -- Can he come back and he's he's. Decent nothing coverage but but can he be a part of this -- -- -- I think Carlos is gonna move on after this year he's. He did not like the -- Jason Campbell is true I was treated the last couple years by the front office you know it's changed over but. You know Carlos looks like a guy that maybe thinks he can go go somewhere else -- -- one corner because the casual like on horse of I think they what Rogers walking free agency and that it creates another need. Next level up on the defense Rocky Macintosh a guy who at times has played great shown some real spurts can he -- up I don't think he's gonna back either when you're finished 31 or 32 in defense. Things have to change not just the scheme so Iraqis realize you don't notice them playing 34 inside linebacker he's a 43 outside guys have. The -- this transition. He's -- tried square pegs in round holes now start time to start getting guys who have experience in the 34 you talk about the transition to a 34 part potentially no position more important and that nose tackle spot knocking Kemoeatu is he the guy going forward to hold down the middle of that defensive line I -- way he's played like he general -- -- a couple of times as you're just getting pushed back. Obviously that Achilles injury that cost of last year he was slow to come back from that but. They have the make nose tackle a priority in the draft getting young guy like greeted -- -- BJ raji. 350 pounds just stick him in there who can play first second third down. All right it's already time death. Think about who's coming into his sleeve and for next year -- -- cells are he's Rondo Allen thanks for checking us out on CS and Washington dot com. More video check out CS in Washington dot com.